There were strong indications on Thursday that the financial problems facing state governments had worsened as many states had yet to start the payment of N30,000 minimum wage 11 months after the deadline given by the Nigeria Labour Congress for the conclusion of negotiations.
The PUNCH gathered that state governments’ foot-dragging on the minimum wage negotiations might not be unconnected with their dwindling finances, including federal allocations and internally generated revenue.
Recall that last month reports from the National Bureau of Statistics showed that the states’ total revenues dropped by N180.4bn in the first half of this year compared to what they made in the second half of 2019.
According to the NBS, the IGR and federal allocations to the 36 states and the Federal Capital Territory in the second half of last year amounted to N1.914tn.
But this dropped to N1.121tn in the first half of 2020, indicating a crash of N181bn or 9.45 per cent when compared to the preceding half-year revenue generation of the states.
The total IGR of the states and the FCT in the second half of 2019 was N640.3bn, while their total allocation from the Federation Account Allocation Committee during the same period was N1.274tn, making a cumulative of N1.914tn.
On Thursday, the Kwara State Governor, AbdulRahman AbdulRazaq, in remarks at the virtual World Bank’s Nigeria Development Update with the theme, ‘Rising to the Challenge: Nigeria’s COVID-19 response’, disclosed that only five or six states were fully implementing the N30,000 minimum wage.
He said state governments had to borrow hundreds of millions of naira before they could pay the November salaries of workers in the various local government councils.
AbdulRazaq stated that Kwara recorded a deficit of N200m in the November salaries of local government workers, adding that Kogi borrowed N500m for the same purpose, while Niger was able to pay 70 per cent.
“Funding the civil service takes away basically all our resources and after that, we have nothing left for anything. So, that’s why you see some state governments resorting to taking loans and bonds, and trying to invest in capital infrastructure development,” he stated.
The governor said one of the committees set up by the All Progressives Congress governors to look at reforming the entire Nigerian political and economic systems recommended the abolishment and reform of the local government system.
AbdulRazaq said, “This third tier of government is dragging down the whole state government structure. It is dragging down the second tier of government.
“In Kwara, we have not implemented the new minimum wage of N30,000 per month; we are still on N18,000, but we are negotiating as N30,000 is the law and we will implement the law early in the new year.
“But an example is the November salary; there was a shortfall of N200m at the third tier of government after the statutory allocation and the local government revenues are combined.”
The governor added, “Now, if you implement the new minimum wage, we are looking at a shortfall of about N600m per month at that level, and it is not Kwara State alone; it is all over the federation.
“Kogi State had to borrow N500m to pay local government workers’ salaries in November. Niger State paid only 70 per cent. Now, 30 states have signed on to the minimum wage and out of those that have signed, probably five or six are paying it.”
He said many states were not paying the full minimum wage, while some others were paying in percentages, grade levels and so on.
AbdulRazaq said many local governments did not prepare budgets but just take money and spend.
He stated, “In some states, the state governments have taken over the finances of the local governments, which should not be the case.
“In Kwara State, we do not do that. We allow them to spend, but they must make sure that the first line charge, which are salaries and pensions, are paid and after they pay that, there’s nothing left to do.”
The governor admitted that local governments were important because of their proximity to the people, but stressed that there should be a rethink of the structure, particularly on how to fund them.
“I can tell you that by this time next year, the local government system will collapse financially; there’s no doubt about it; the system will collapse financially. Because we have to be borrowing money to keep up that system,” AbdulRazaq added.
KWSG yet to implement minimum wage – Labour
The Kwara State Government has yet to implement the N30,000 minimum wage for workers in the civil service and local government councils.
The state Chairman of the Nigeria Labour Congress, Issa Ore; and the Chairman, state Joint Negotiating Council, Salihu Sulaiman, told one of our correspondents in Ilorin on Thursday that the labour leaders and the government had yet to sign the minimum wage agreement.
Ore said, “The government and labour have not yet signed the agreement on the payment of minimum wage to workers in the state public service. We have not agreed on the minimum wage to be paid to workers in the state.”
Sulaiman also said, “The minimum wage agreement was about to be signed when COVID-19 broke out, but after the lockdown, the government came with another thing, and when we decided to go on strike, the governor went to the Industrial Court in Akure, and one of the things he asked from the court was whether he has power to negotiate for local government workers in view of the local government autonomy being proposed.
“But, we told him that if he could not negotiate for local government workers, he should pay the state civil service workers.”
COVID-19 delays full minimum wage payment in Ekiti
In Ekiti State, it was gathered that the COVID-19 pandemic worsened the finances of the state and had delayed the implementation of the minimum wage.
Currently, only workers on grade levels 1 to 6 have been enjoying the minimum wage since October last year.
But Governor Kayode Fayemi, while presenting the 2021 budget to the state House of Assembly, raised hopes that the minimum wage would be paid next year to all workers in the state.
The Chairman, Trade Union Congress in Ekiti State, Sola Adigun, said on Thursday that negotiations between organised labour and the government on the minimum wage and consequential adjustment, which resumed about three weeks ago, would continue today (Friday).
Adigun stated, “We are resuming negotiations tomorrow (Friday). Before the COVID-19 lockdown in March, we were on the verge of putting signatures on paper, but we had a challenge with that of the health sector. We have reached agreements in other sectors.
“Negotiations resumed about three weeks ago. The government and labour representatives will meet on Friday morning.”
Minimum wage implementation suspended in Gombe
In Gombe State, the implementation of the minimum wage, which was suspended following the outbreak of COVID-19 in March, has not resumed.
The state chapter of the NLC said what the state required was the resumption of the new minimum wage payment.
The state Secretary of the NLC, Shuaibu Chiroma, said workers were awaiting the decision of Governor Inuwa Yahaya to resume the payment from January 2021.
“Gombe State had finished negotiations and started payment before the COVID-19 set in. It is no longer about negotiations but restoration. The governor has made pronouncements when he was presenting his budget. He said he would restore the minimum wage by January 2021. We are waiting for him,” Chiroma stated.
Borno LG workers, teachers yet to get minimum wage
The Chairman, NLC, Borno State, Abiso Bulama, said local government workers and teachers had yet to start enjoying the new minimum wage.
Bulama stated that the state government had constituted two committees currently verifying the local government employees and teachers, adding that the full implementation of the minimum wage for the affected workers would commence when the verification was concluded.
C’River adds N2,000 to workers’ salaries
Similarly, the Cross River State Government has not started implementing the minimum wage.
The state Chairman of the NLC, Monday Ugbodim, said the implementation would start in January.
“Going by the memorandum of understanding that labour signed with the state government in February, the full implementation of the minimum wage will commence in January 2021. What was added to civil servants’ wages was N2,000 and N3,000, depending on the grade level.”
Enugu primary school teachers, LG, parastatal workers not earning minimum wage yet
The Enugu State Government has commenced the full implementation of minimum wage to all levels of civil servants except parastatal workers, local government employees and primary school teachers.
The Chairman of the state Joint Public Service Negotiating Council, Chukwuma Igbokwe, told one of our correspondents on the telephone that primary school teachers and local government workers were not being paid the minimum wage yet.
Igbokwe stated, “Employees of parastatals in Enugu State have not started receiving minimum wage payment.
“Also, the primary school teachers and local government employees have not been paid the minimum wage.”
Kano paying minimum wage, deducting workers’ salaries
Although the Kano State Government is implementing the minimum wage, it is at the same time making deductions from workers’ salaries.
An official of the NLC in the state, who spoke on condition of anonymity, told The PUNCH on Thursday that the government had yet to refund the deductions from workers’ salaries for three months after it started the implementation of the minimum wage in December 2019.
He said the state government promised to refund the deducted salaries before the end of August 2020, but it had yet to fulfil the promise.
The official explained, “Even last month (November), the state government deducted the salaries of workers without any explanation as to why it took the action.
“The state government deducted the workers’ salaries in May, June and July. It also deducted the November salaries.”
When contacted, the state NLC Chairman, Ado Minjibir, said in a text message that he was currently in Abuja attending a meeting.
Minimum wage not yet implemented in Ebonyi – NLC
The implementation of the minimum wage has yet to commence in Ebonyi State.
The Chairman of the state chapter of the NLC, Ikechukwu Nwafor, stated this in a telephone interview with one of our correspondents in Abakaliki on Thursday.
Nwafo said, “Neither the previous N18,000 nor the N30,000 new minimum wage is being implemented in Ebonyi State.
“The state is living in a shadow of itself, because of lies and pseudo promises. This has made everybody to watch the government from afar. No civil servant can tell you that he or she has received the new national minimum wage.
“Here in Ebonyi State, no level one or level six civil servant receives anything different from the paltry sums they have been receiving since 2015. I stand to be challenged and I will prove my point anywhere, anytime.”
Ogun has commenced full payment, says NLC
However, the NLC in Ogun State said the state government had begun the full implementation of the new minimum wage.
The Chairman of the NLC in the state, Emmanuel Bankole, said this on Thursday in an interview with one of our correspondents.
Bankole said the state government did not discriminate against any level, adding that all workers were being considered for full payment.
“Yes, the government has commenced full payment to all categories of workers,” he stated.
NLC warns governors against borrowing N17tn from pension funds
Meanwhile, the NLC has threatened to mobilise Nigerian workers in protest against moves by state governors to borrow N17tn from pension funds purportedly for infrastructural development.
The union asked the state chief executives to steer clear of the pension funds and warned them against tampering with the money.
Speaking at the 47th National Executive Council meeting of the Medical and Health Workers’ Union of Nigeria in Abuja on Thursday, the NLC President, Ayuba Wabba, insisted that the governors had no authority over the funds.
The Nigerian Governors’ Forum had last week endorsed the proposal of the Chairman of the National Economic Council Ad hoc Committee, Mallam Nasir El-Rufai, to borrow N17tn from the pension fund for infrastructural development.
But reacting to the proposal, Ayuba said, “Pension is not for borrowing; pension money is the retirement savings of workers; it cannot be borrowed. It’s like money in your savings account that nobody can borrow.
“You must go through the banks and in this case, you must go through the PFAs and their guidelines; even the guidelines they want to play down, but to the glory of God, the board of PenCom has been constituted.
“I stand here to represent all of you (workers); we are not going to agree; less than five per cent of the states are keying into the contributory pension scheme, yet they want to borrow the money. The bulk of the money is from the Federal Government workers and private sector workers; so, how do you want to borrow from where you have not sown?”
The NLC leader lamented that over 18 state governments were delaying the implementation of the new national minimum wage, noting that it was unheard of that the same governments would want to borrow the workers’ pensions.
He added, “It’s not free money, and let me sound a note of warning: any day that we hear that the pension fund, our money has been borrowed, I will declare a protest and everybody is going to be on the street to protect our hard-earned money.
“The money belongs to workers; we contribute that money so that when we retire, we can have something for retirement, so they have no say whatsoever; both the principal and the capital belong to us.”